How to Make Your Own Brown Sugar

Brown sugar is a sweetener which is made by mixing white sugar with black treacle, which gives it it’s brown colour, soft and moist texture, and rich, caramel-like flavour. The amount of black treacle added determines whether the sugar is light or dark brown. Light brown sugar has a milder taste and dark brown sugar has a deeper, more intense flavour. Brown sugar retains moisture, which helps baked goods stay soft and chewy. 

Brown sugar is used in many sweet and savoury dishes. Here are its main uses:
Baking: Brown sugar is commonly known to be used in sweet bakes like cookies, cakes, brownies, and muffins because it adds moisture and creates a soft, chewy texture along with a rich, caramel-like flavour. 
Sweetening foods: It is also used to add sweetness to dishes and drinks like porridge, cereals, coffee, tea, and fruit to give a deeper sweetness than white sugar. 
Sauces and glazes: Brown sugar is used in barbecue sauces, teriyaki sauce, and glazes for meats like gammon as well as vegetables like glazed carrots. Brown sugar helps balance salty or spicy flavours and helps with the browning. 
Marinades: It adds sweetness and helps tenderize meats when used in marinades for things like chicken wings and also gammon joints. 
Desserts and toppings: Brown sugar is used in toppings like streusel, crumbles, and caramel-style sauces, like salted caramel sauce and toffee sauce. 
Preserving and flavouring: It is sometimes used in pickling or curing foods to enhance flavour. Overall, brown sugar is valued for the warmth, moisture, and depth of flavour it adds to both sweet and savoury dishes.

Removing or swapping brown sugar in a recipe can affect the texture and flavour of the baked good or dish. However, if you have run out at home, here is a simple recipe you can use to make your own.

Ingredients
- 200g Granulated/Caster Sugar
-  1 tbsp Black Treacle (to make light brown sugar)
-  2 tbsp Black Treacle (to make dark brown sugar)

1- Put the sugar and black treacle in a bowl. 
2- Mix well with a fork or spoon until the colour is even and there are no streaks. (You can also use a food processor and pulse for a few seconds.)

- If it’s too light, add a tiny bit more molasses. 
- If it gets clumpy, just break it up or pulse it again. Store it in an airtight container so it stays soft for up to 6 months.

1.       Sticky Toffee Puddings Recipe | Dr. Oetker
2.      Vegan Coffee Cake Recipe | Dr. Oetker
3.      Pumpkin Spiced Cupcake Recipe | Dr. Oetker
4.      Brown Butter and Chocolate Chunk Cookies Recipe | Dr. Oetker
5.      Snickers Cake Recipe | Dr. Oetker
6.      Banana Muffin Recipe | Dr. Oetker
7.      Rhubarb Crumble Cake Recipe | Dr. Oetker
8.      Gingerbread Biscuits Recipe | Dr. Oetker
9.      White Chocolate Chai Sugar Cookies Recipe | Dr. Oetker
10.    Vegan Apple-Cinnamon Rolls Recipe | Dr. Oetker

What Can I Use if I Don’t Have Brown Sugar?
If you don’t have brown sugar, following this recipe will be the same alternative. However, there are several easy substitutes you can use, depending on what you’re making:
Caster or Granulated Sugar: You can use white sugar, but the flavour will be lighter, and the texture may be a bit drier. Honey or maple syrup: These can replace brown sugar in some recipes, especially sauces or marinades. Use about 225g cup of honey or syrup for every 220g brown sugar and reduce other liquids slightly. Coconut sugar: This has a similar colour and caramel-like flavour and can usually be swapped 1:1. Raw sugars (like demerara): These work well as substitutes, though they are coarser and may not dissolve as easily. The best choice depends on whether you want to match the moisture, flavour, or texture of brown sugar in your recipe.

Is Golden Caster Sugar the Same as Light Brown Sugar?
No, Golden caster sugar is not the same as light brown sugar. Golden caster sugar is a fine, dry, golden-coloured sugar with a mild caramel flavour. Light brown sugar contains black treacle, which gives it a darker colour, softer texture, and a richer, more intense caramel taste.

Is Light Brown Sugar the Same as Light Muscovado Sugar?
Yes, these sugars are the same.
 

Check out our other handy baking tips on Methods of Cake Making or Fruit Compote.