
First up, split the custard into three bowls. (2 of them should have slightly more custard in than the others.)
Into one of the fuller bowls, stir in ½ tsp caramel flavouring and 2 tsp of green food colour gel… this will be your Frankenstein slime. Into the second, mix ½ tsp caramel flavouring and 2 tsp of orange food colour gel… this will be your pumpkin guts! And into the last bowl, mix ¼ tsp caramel flavouring and 2 tsp of wicked violet gel—witches’ brew! Give them all a good stir until they are all combined.
Next, crush your Oreos into spooky soil. You can smash them with a rolling pin or whizz them in a blender until they look like graveyard dirt.
Now, grab your clear cups. With a black marker, draw grinning pumpkin faces and Scary Frankenstein’s faces. Leave a few cups blank for the “mystery ghosts.”
Now it’s time to start to layer the Haunted Desserts:
For the ghostly cups: Start with a scoop of green custard, then bury it under a layer of oreo dirt. Next, pour on some purple custard, cover it with more graveyard soil, then add a layer of orange custard, and finish with one last creepy crumble of Oreos.
For the pumpkin cups: Fill with pumpkin-orange custard, then sprinkle with Oreo dirt.
For Frankenstein’s cups: Fill with monster-green custard, then cover with Oreo dirt.
Finally, it’s time to get creative—top with spooky sprinkles.
Your Boo-tiful Custard Cups are ready to haunt hungry tummies!
RELATED RECIPES

Marshmallow Spider Web Cupcakes

Halloween Buttercream Kiss Cake

Christmas Chocolate Truffles

Pecan and White Chocolate Brownie Trees

Bat Cupcakes

Brownie Tiramisu

Halloween Unicorn Chocolate Cupcakes Recipe